Comparaison entre deux approches d’enseignement par investigation sur le thème de la flottabilité en collège : la problématisation favorisée dans l’approche hypothético-déductive
New style of teaching science (as inquiry based science teaching) appeared in the French curricula during these last years. Our study focuses on two kind of inquiry based teachings and propose to identify which promote in the better way the processes of problematization during a debate. The theoreti...
Κύριοι συγγραφείς: | , |
---|---|
Μορφή: | Online |
Γλώσσα: | English |
Έκδοση: |
Urray
2014
|
Θέματα: |
Physics education, investigation, problematization, buoyancy, video analysis, comparison of teaching
Proximal function of language, thematic segmentation, representation scenic, cognitive conflict, TIC
|
Διαθέσιμο Online: | https://pasithee.library.upatras.gr/ejupUNESCOchair/article/view/2202 |
id |
oai:ojs.pasithee.library.upatras.gr:article-2202 |
---|---|
record_format |
ojs |
spelling |
oai:ojs.pasithee.library.upatras.gr:article-22022019-09-12T05:36:40Z Comparaison entre deux approches d’enseignement par investigation sur le thème de la flottabilité en collège : la problématisation favorisée dans l’approche hypothético-déductive DERRADJ, CORALIE GIVRY, DAMIEN Physics education, investigation, problematization, buoyancy, video analysis, comparison of teaching New style of teaching science (as inquiry based science teaching) appeared in the French curricula during these last years. Our study focuses on two kind of inquiry based teachings and propose to identify which promote in the better way the processes of problematization during a debate. The theoretical framework of problematization, allowed us to compare two types of inquiry based teachings in two classes of grade 7th having the same problem to solved based on the phenomenon of buoyancy. These two teachings differ in the organization of students' investigation before the debate. The first teaching asks the students to resolve the problem without writing hypothesis, whereas the second necessitates that students write some hypothesis before to handling the experiment. The analysis of video transcriptions of the two sequences have allowed us to show that writing hypothesis seems to promote explanations of students in the register of models during a debate in class, which could allow to them to problematize in a better way. Urray 2014-10-08 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion application/pdf https://pasithee.library.upatras.gr/ejupUNESCOchair/article/view/2202 10.26220/une.2202 Educational Journal of the University of Patras UNESCO Chair; Vol. 2, N. 1 (2015) - Colloque SIEST Méditerranée, Rabat 2014 Educational Journal of the University of Patras UNESCO Chair; Vol. 2, N. 1 (2015) - Colloque SIEST Méditerranée, Rabat 2014 2241-9152 eng https://pasithee.library.upatras.gr/ejupUNESCOchair/article/view/2202/2377 |
institution |
UPatras |
collection |
Pasithee |
language |
English |
topic |
Conceptual knowledge, procedural knowledge, fractions, rational numbers, secondary students Genetic screening, arguments, Bioethics and Biotechnology students Physics Education, modern physics teaching, quantum concepts ICT, video, counselling, professional orientation, business administration Problem solving, practice, difficulties, help, performance Special needs, autism spectrum disorder, science education, alternative conceptions on mechanics Narration, digital storytelling, Blendspace, Web 2.0 tools Textbooks, evaluation, teacher, student, educational policy Digital instruction, augmented reality, devolution, teaching-learning, applications, activity, informatics Professionalism, in-service teachers, pre-primary, primary education, perceptions Socio-cultural, historical approach, preschoolers’ interactions, explanatory schemes, conversational approach, science thinking and learning in early childhood Teaching goals, science teachers, ideal teacher, philosophy of education Teachers’ questions, classroom, analysis grid, TP of geology Digital signal Processing, Simulation Block, pedagogical sequence, conceptual model Expert teacher, prediction, time, technical drawing Learning games, epistemic games, contract, setting, simulation, mechanical waves, inquiry process Plants, scientist students, learning process, epistemological obstacle, quantitative study Intercultural sensitivity, interaction engagement, enjoyment, attentiveness, confidence, cultural differences, respect, Greek teachers Cultural capital, educational expectations, occupational expectations, primary school, natives, immigrants Earth sciences concepts, nursery school, primary school, sedimentary rock, geological time Artefact, technical object, categorization, learning, technological education Education for sustainable development, preschool children’s environmental reasoning, attitudes about environmental issues Concept formation, philosophical theories, biology education, vertebrate classes Primary school pupils, sustainability, behavioural theories, sustainability behaviour, pro-social behaviours, sustainability knowledge Entrepreneurship, education, didactic approach, teaching method 3D printer, creative design, rapid prototyping, additive manufacturing, activity Administrative leadership style, democratic leadership style, autocratic leadership style, transactional leadership style and teacher effectiveness DREEM, validation, educational department, educational environment, undergraduate students Teaching practice, higher education, TACD, determinant of action, organic chemistry Didactic of physics, mechanical work, diagrams, semiotic actions Mathematical training, probabilities, perceived self-efficacy beliefs, preschool teachers, inquiry-based approach Approach skills, program, investigation, enforcement Curriculum contents, curriculum analyses, curriculum content appropriateness and relevance, indigenous scientific knowledge, basic science curriculum Educational design, Massive Open Online Course, motivation, interaction Early childhood education, artmaking, visual languages, communication, documentation Physics education, investigation, problematization, buoyancy, video analysis, comparison of teaching Environmental Education, teachers’ conceptions, Togo, anthropocentric attitudes, ecocentric attitudes, multivariate analyses Biotic system, energy chain, task condition, student’s action, experimental protocol Ideology, education, Ideological State Apparatus, materialism, consciousness Electrical risks, domestic electricity, scientific education, prevention, conceptions, teachers Documentational genesis, mathematics, professional knowledge, resources, software Teaching practice, teachers, undergraduate students, exploratory study Critical reflection, teacher’s education, practicum, teacher’s preparation, reflective skills Autism spectrum disorder, science education, folk physics test Precursor model, socio cognitive approach, primary education, light, shadow Online communities of practice, virtual communities of practice, systematic review Effects, systematic approach, students’ understanding, tonal values, tertiary institutions Proximal function of language, thematic segmentation, representation scenic, cognitive conflict, TIC Educational engineering, motivation, commitment, evaluation Anthropology, teaching, heuristic research Teaching practices, trigonometric formulas, ICT Didactics, assessment, curriculum, training, performances Didactic transposition, science education, manual analysis, atom Conceptions, students 5 to 7 years, time, speed, methodology, qualitative analysis Intercultural activities, reflection, narratives, transformative learning Art education, artistic creation, education, subjective teaching, creation Teaching practice, JATD, automatic, game descriptors Comparatism, dietitian school, epistemic games, social practice of reference, didactic transposition Professional communication skills, situational teaching, teaching professional Web simulation, experimental design, adaptive scaffolds, biology, high school Digital educational scenarios, AESOP, mechanical engineering, constructivism Inquiry, learning tool, social media and university students Teacher practices, joint action, interactive decision, technical object Bac-3 and Bac + 3 project, chemistry, semiotic register, modelling process Teaching practices, JATD, didactic action, didactic game, practical epistemology Analyse lexicométrique, analyse thématique, triangulation méthodologique, biodiversité, curriculum Aspects of adulthood, emerging adulthood, higher education students, roles of adults Science teacher, teacher training, ground realities Complex technological system, car, energy, environment, secondary education Expert teacher, task, difficulty, prediction, technical drawing Erasmus, student mobility, emerging adulthood, higher education, student development Greek ethnic schools, spatiality, heterotopia, third space, intercultural and language learning, diaspora Ecological reasoning, nature’s predictability, two-tier questionnaire, nature views Schooling of disabled pupils, school ancillaries, science education, partnership Initial training, pedagogical knowledge learning, identification methodology, activity control feedback loop, aware and unaware learning Force on the tooth, three dimensional perception, graphic representation, digital models Teaching practices, TACD, practical epistemology, transactions, transistor Critical Reflection, art in education, teachers’ education, university pedagogy, transformative learning Immigrants, socio-economic status, habitus, educational aspirations and expectations, young people’s educational choices Large-scale electricity generation systems, energy chain model, elementary education Sentiment analysis, opinion mining, education, commercial systems, benchmark |
spellingShingle |
Conceptual knowledge, procedural knowledge, fractions, rational numbers, secondary students Genetic screening, arguments, Bioethics and Biotechnology students Physics Education, modern physics teaching, quantum concepts ICT, video, counselling, professional orientation, business administration Problem solving, practice, difficulties, help, performance Special needs, autism spectrum disorder, science education, alternative conceptions on mechanics Narration, digital storytelling, Blendspace, Web 2.0 tools Textbooks, evaluation, teacher, student, educational policy Digital instruction, augmented reality, devolution, teaching-learning, applications, activity, informatics Professionalism, in-service teachers, pre-primary, primary education, perceptions Socio-cultural, historical approach, preschoolers’ interactions, explanatory schemes, conversational approach, science thinking and learning in early childhood Teaching goals, science teachers, ideal teacher, philosophy of education Teachers’ questions, classroom, analysis grid, TP of geology Digital signal Processing, Simulation Block, pedagogical sequence, conceptual model Expert teacher, prediction, time, technical drawing Learning games, epistemic games, contract, setting, simulation, mechanical waves, inquiry process Plants, scientist students, learning process, epistemological obstacle, quantitative study Intercultural sensitivity, interaction engagement, enjoyment, attentiveness, confidence, cultural differences, respect, Greek teachers Cultural capital, educational expectations, occupational expectations, primary school, natives, immigrants Earth sciences concepts, nursery school, primary school, sedimentary rock, geological time Artefact, technical object, categorization, learning, technological education Education for sustainable development, preschool children’s environmental reasoning, attitudes about environmental issues Concept formation, philosophical theories, biology education, vertebrate classes Primary school pupils, sustainability, behavioural theories, sustainability behaviour, pro-social behaviours, sustainability knowledge Entrepreneurship, education, didactic approach, teaching method 3D printer, creative design, rapid prototyping, additive manufacturing, activity Administrative leadership style, democratic leadership style, autocratic leadership style, transactional leadership style and teacher effectiveness DREEM, validation, educational department, educational environment, undergraduate students Teaching practice, higher education, TACD, determinant of action, organic chemistry Didactic of physics, mechanical work, diagrams, semiotic actions Mathematical training, probabilities, perceived self-efficacy beliefs, preschool teachers, inquiry-based approach Approach skills, program, investigation, enforcement Curriculum contents, curriculum analyses, curriculum content appropriateness and relevance, indigenous scientific knowledge, basic science curriculum Educational design, Massive Open Online Course, motivation, interaction Early childhood education, artmaking, visual languages, communication, documentation Physics education, investigation, problematization, buoyancy, video analysis, comparison of teaching Environmental Education, teachers’ conceptions, Togo, anthropocentric attitudes, ecocentric attitudes, multivariate analyses Biotic system, energy chain, task condition, student’s action, experimental protocol Ideology, education, Ideological State Apparatus, materialism, consciousness Electrical risks, domestic electricity, scientific education, prevention, conceptions, teachers Documentational genesis, mathematics, professional knowledge, resources, software Teaching practice, teachers, undergraduate students, exploratory study Critical reflection, teacher’s education, practicum, teacher’s preparation, reflective skills Autism spectrum disorder, science education, folk physics test Precursor model, socio cognitive approach, primary education, light, shadow Online communities of practice, virtual communities of practice, systematic review Effects, systematic approach, students’ understanding, tonal values, tertiary institutions Proximal function of language, thematic segmentation, representation scenic, cognitive conflict, TIC Educational engineering, motivation, commitment, evaluation Anthropology, teaching, heuristic research Teaching practices, trigonometric formulas, ICT Didactics, assessment, curriculum, training, performances Didactic transposition, science education, manual analysis, atom Conceptions, students 5 to 7 years, time, speed, methodology, qualitative analysis Intercultural activities, reflection, narratives, transformative learning Art education, artistic creation, education, subjective teaching, creation Teaching practice, JATD, automatic, game descriptors Comparatism, dietitian school, epistemic games, social practice of reference, didactic transposition Professional communication skills, situational teaching, teaching professional Web simulation, experimental design, adaptive scaffolds, biology, high school Digital educational scenarios, AESOP, mechanical engineering, constructivism Inquiry, learning tool, social media and university students Teacher practices, joint action, interactive decision, technical object Bac-3 and Bac + 3 project, chemistry, semiotic register, modelling process Teaching practices, JATD, didactic action, didactic game, practical epistemology Analyse lexicométrique, analyse thématique, triangulation méthodologique, biodiversité, curriculum Aspects of adulthood, emerging adulthood, higher education students, roles of adults Science teacher, teacher training, ground realities Complex technological system, car, energy, environment, secondary education Expert teacher, task, difficulty, prediction, technical drawing Erasmus, student mobility, emerging adulthood, higher education, student development Greek ethnic schools, spatiality, heterotopia, third space, intercultural and language learning, diaspora Ecological reasoning, nature’s predictability, two-tier questionnaire, nature views Schooling of disabled pupils, school ancillaries, science education, partnership Initial training, pedagogical knowledge learning, identification methodology, activity control feedback loop, aware and unaware learning Force on the tooth, three dimensional perception, graphic representation, digital models Teaching practices, TACD, practical epistemology, transactions, transistor Critical Reflection, art in education, teachers’ education, university pedagogy, transformative learning Immigrants, socio-economic status, habitus, educational aspirations and expectations, young people’s educational choices Large-scale electricity generation systems, energy chain model, elementary education Sentiment analysis, opinion mining, education, commercial systems, benchmark DERRADJ, CORALIE GIVRY, DAMIEN Comparaison entre deux approches d’enseignement par investigation sur le thème de la flottabilité en collège : la problématisation favorisée dans l’approche hypothético-déductive |
topic_facet |
Conceptual knowledge, procedural knowledge, fractions, rational numbers, secondary students Genetic screening, arguments, Bioethics and Biotechnology students Physics Education, modern physics teaching, quantum concepts ICT, video, counselling, professional orientation, business administration Problem solving, practice, difficulties, help, performance Special needs, autism spectrum disorder, science education, alternative conceptions on mechanics Narration, digital storytelling, Blendspace, Web 2.0 tools Textbooks, evaluation, teacher, student, educational policy Digital instruction, augmented reality, devolution, teaching-learning, applications, activity, informatics Professionalism, in-service teachers, pre-primary, primary education, perceptions Socio-cultural, historical approach, preschoolers’ interactions, explanatory schemes, conversational approach, science thinking and learning in early childhood Teaching goals, science teachers, ideal teacher, philosophy of education Teachers’ questions, classroom, analysis grid, TP of geology Digital signal Processing, Simulation Block, pedagogical sequence, conceptual model Expert teacher, prediction, time, technical drawing Learning games, epistemic games, contract, setting, simulation, mechanical waves, inquiry process Plants, scientist students, learning process, epistemological obstacle, quantitative study Intercultural sensitivity, interaction engagement, enjoyment, attentiveness, confidence, cultural differences, respect, Greek teachers Cultural capital, educational expectations, occupational expectations, primary school, natives, immigrants Earth sciences concepts, nursery school, primary school, sedimentary rock, geological time Artefact, technical object, categorization, learning, technological education Education for sustainable development, preschool children’s environmental reasoning, attitudes about environmental issues Concept formation, philosophical theories, biology education, vertebrate classes Primary school pupils, sustainability, behavioural theories, sustainability behaviour, pro-social behaviours, sustainability knowledge Entrepreneurship, education, didactic approach, teaching method 3D printer, creative design, rapid prototyping, additive manufacturing, activity Administrative leadership style, democratic leadership style, autocratic leadership style, transactional leadership style and teacher effectiveness DREEM, validation, educational department, educational environment, undergraduate students Teaching practice, higher education, TACD, determinant of action, organic chemistry Didactic of physics, mechanical work, diagrams, semiotic actions Mathematical training, probabilities, perceived self-efficacy beliefs, preschool teachers, inquiry-based approach Approach skills, program, investigation, enforcement Curriculum contents, curriculum analyses, curriculum content appropriateness and relevance, indigenous scientific knowledge, basic science curriculum Educational design, Massive Open Online Course, motivation, interaction Early childhood education, artmaking, visual languages, communication, documentation Physics education, investigation, problematization, buoyancy, video analysis, comparison of teaching Environmental Education, teachers’ conceptions, Togo, anthropocentric attitudes, ecocentric attitudes, multivariate analyses Biotic system, energy chain, task condition, student’s action, experimental protocol Ideology, education, Ideological State Apparatus, materialism, consciousness Electrical risks, domestic electricity, scientific education, prevention, conceptions, teachers Documentational genesis, mathematics, professional knowledge, resources, software Teaching practice, teachers, undergraduate students, exploratory study Critical reflection, teacher’s education, practicum, teacher’s preparation, reflective skills Autism spectrum disorder, science education, folk physics test Precursor model, socio cognitive approach, primary education, light, shadow Online communities of practice, virtual communities of practice, systematic review Effects, systematic approach, students’ understanding, tonal values, tertiary institutions Proximal function of language, thematic segmentation, representation scenic, cognitive conflict, TIC Educational engineering, motivation, commitment, evaluation Anthropology, teaching, heuristic research Teaching practices, trigonometric formulas, ICT Didactics, assessment, curriculum, training, performances Didactic transposition, science education, manual analysis, atom Conceptions, students 5 to 7 years, time, speed, methodology, qualitative analysis Intercultural activities, reflection, narratives, transformative learning Art education, artistic creation, education, subjective teaching, creation Teaching practice, JATD, automatic, game descriptors Comparatism, dietitian school, epistemic games, social practice of reference, didactic transposition Professional communication skills, situational teaching, teaching professional Web simulation, experimental design, adaptive scaffolds, biology, high school Digital educational scenarios, AESOP, mechanical engineering, constructivism Inquiry, learning tool, social media and university students Teacher practices, joint action, interactive decision, technical object Bac-3 and Bac + 3 project, chemistry, semiotic register, modelling process Teaching practices, JATD, didactic action, didactic game, practical epistemology Analyse lexicométrique, analyse thématique, triangulation méthodologique, biodiversité, curriculum Aspects of adulthood, emerging adulthood, higher education students, roles of adults Science teacher, teacher training, ground realities Complex technological system, car, energy, environment, secondary education Expert teacher, task, difficulty, prediction, technical drawing Erasmus, student mobility, emerging adulthood, higher education, student development Greek ethnic schools, spatiality, heterotopia, third space, intercultural and language learning, diaspora Ecological reasoning, nature’s predictability, two-tier questionnaire, nature views Schooling of disabled pupils, school ancillaries, science education, partnership Initial training, pedagogical knowledge learning, identification methodology, activity control feedback loop, aware and unaware learning Force on the tooth, three dimensional perception, graphic representation, digital models Teaching practices, TACD, practical epistemology, transactions, transistor Critical Reflection, art in education, teachers’ education, university pedagogy, transformative learning Immigrants, socio-economic status, habitus, educational aspirations and expectations, young people’s educational choices Large-scale electricity generation systems, energy chain model, elementary education Sentiment analysis, opinion mining, education, commercial systems, benchmark |
format |
Online |
author |
DERRADJ, CORALIE GIVRY, DAMIEN |
author_facet |
DERRADJ, CORALIE GIVRY, DAMIEN |
author_sort |
DERRADJ, CORALIE |
title |
Comparaison entre deux approches d’enseignement par investigation sur le thème de la flottabilité en collège : la problématisation favorisée dans l’approche hypothético-déductive |
title_short |
Comparaison entre deux approches d’enseignement par investigation sur le thème de la flottabilité en collège : la problématisation favorisée dans l’approche hypothético-déductive |
title_full |
Comparaison entre deux approches d’enseignement par investigation sur le thème de la flottabilité en collège : la problématisation favorisée dans l’approche hypothético-déductive |
title_fullStr |
Comparaison entre deux approches d’enseignement par investigation sur le thème de la flottabilité en collège : la problématisation favorisée dans l’approche hypothético-déductive |
title_full_unstemmed |
Comparaison entre deux approches d’enseignement par investigation sur le thème de la flottabilité en collège : la problématisation favorisée dans l’approche hypothético-déductive |
title_sort |
comparaison entre deux approches d’enseignement par investigation sur le thème de la flottabilité en collège : la problématisation favorisée dans l’approche hypothético-déductive |
description |
New style of teaching science (as inquiry based science teaching) appeared in the French curricula during these last years. Our study focuses on two kind of inquiry based teachings and propose to identify which promote in the better way the processes of problematization during a debate. The theoretical framework of problematization, allowed us to compare two types of inquiry based teachings in two classes of grade 7th having the same problem to solved based on the phenomenon of buoyancy. These two teachings differ in the organization of students' investigation before the debate. The first teaching asks the students to resolve the problem without writing hypothesis, whereas the second necessitates that students write some hypothesis before to handling the experiment. The analysis of video transcriptions of the two sequences have allowed us to show that writing hypothesis seems to promote explanations of students in the register of models during a debate in class, which could allow to them to problematize in a better way. |
publisher |
Urray |
publishDate |
2014 |
url |
https://pasithee.library.upatras.gr/ejupUNESCOchair/article/view/2202 |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT derradjcoralie comparaisonentredeuxapprochesdenseignementparinvestigationsurlethemedelaflottabiliteencollegelaproblematisationfavoriseedanslapprochehypotheticodeductive AT givrydamien comparaisonentredeuxapprochesdenseignementparinvestigationsurlethemedelaflottabiliteencollegelaproblematisationfavoriseedanslapprochehypotheticodeductive |
_version_ |
1771298423264247808 |